Showing posts with label censorship. Show all posts
Showing posts with label censorship. Show all posts

Tuesday, August 12, 2014

No Information Power Crisis

Nik Gowing, Visiting Fellow at the University of Oxford Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism and
a former presenter for the BBC, talked on "Skyful of Lies and Black Swans: Who Controls Shifting Information Power in Crises?" at the Australian National University in Canberra. He argues that IT and the Internet are disruptive game changers. This was a very frustrating presentation, as Mr. Gowing did not explain his thesis, assuming that the audience had read his previous work. He seemed to be saying that senior people in government and industry were not sufficiently familiar with the Internet and it was changing decision making. That would have been new and interesting, if the presentation was being made twenty years ago, but is not news in 2014.

Unfortunately, Mr. Gowing spent the first five minutes warning of "disruption" but did not make clear what this disruption is. He referred to a "digital bullet train of disruptions (quipping the Sydney to Canberra train is not a bullet train). This was delivered in strident tones, but still did not make clear as to what he is warning of. Mr. Gowing, warned there are many "flat earthers" in government who do not understand, but again he did not say what it was they did not understand. He asked how much public policy understood this "new nervous system for the planet", but still without explaining what it was. He said that the evening news is not what it is about, again not saying what "it" is.

Mr. Gowing stated that the were now many billions of mobile phones in operation, creating a whole new public information environment. At this point, more than 15 minutes into the presentation, he started to provide some useful information, but not much. The basic theme seemed to be that there had been a sudden change in the way news cycles operate and organisations need to change they way they work in response. But these changes have been happening, with the development of the Internet and mobile devices, over the last twenty years. Mr. Gowing did not make it clear what has changed recently which is different to the last two decades of development.

Obviously, not all in government have become fully conversant with the implications of the Internet (the Australian Attorney General being a prime example of someone unable, or unwilling, to understand the basics of the Internet). However, I don't agree with Mr. Gowings' view, which appears to be that there is a general lack of understanding of the Internet in government and organisations throughout the world. There are many who are aware of the implications and the everyday usefulness of the technology in organisations world wide. In the Australian Parliament, for example, the Communications Minister Mr. Malcolm_Turnbull MP, and Senator Kate Lundy are examples of leaders comfortable with the Internet.

Mr. Gowing argues that existing organisational structures need to be changed to accommodate the Internet. It is not clear what changes he has in mind, or if he has any specific proposals. In my work on incorporating the Internet into the process of government, professional organisations and educational institutions, I have taken an evolutionary approach, where the new technology is incorporated into existing processes and structures. It may well be that a more revolutionary approach is needed, but if so Mr. Gowing needs to present evidence for why (rather than just anecdotes from news items) and proposals as to how.

Mr. Gowing showed video from a Canberra prison and Tasmanian bushfires. He seemed to be saying that these videos had great impact when used in the media. If so, this is hardly a new idea. Also that these videos appeared in the conventional media and so seemed to contradict Mr. Gowing's thesis that the Internet had eclipsed the old media. He then showed a video "live" from a helicopter in Antarctica, citing this as a revolutionary development. However, live reports have been available for decades. On small scale, Senator Lundy and myself sent a "live" report from a hot air balloon over Canberra, using a mobile phone in 1996. In 1995 I prepared online reports from a military exercise for the Australian Department of Defence, which used satellite and mobile technology (later looking at how to incorporate the technology into military command and control).

Mr. Gowing's asserted that governments had not learned to cope with the Internet and it threatened state control. However, in 2003 I visited the web staff of the People's Daily newspaper in Beijing (while there to help with the web site for the 2008 Olympics). The staff, and the senior academics who advised them, had a very sophisticated view of the web and how to make use of it on behalf of the government. The ANU recently hosted a symposium on current use of the Internet in China, which showed that  China has developed ways to accommodate the Internet within their form of government.

In the last two decades, companies and government agencies have learned to deal with the Internet. Organisations have trained teams of specialists and systems to address online information. Organisation spokespersons receive training in how to deal with the Internet. The Australian Government Chief Technology Officer (AGCTO) and his staff have considerable expertise in this area. The ANU trains staff to work with the Internet (and IT professionals to design specialist software to help them).

It may well be that those who research and teach governance and politics are not familiar with the work carried out on the use of the Internet elsewhere in academia. At the ANU the part of the university which is comfortable with the internet (Computer Science and Information Systems), perhaps needs to collaborate more with the governance and strategic policy areas. Similarly, it may be that senior governance levels in organisations and government are not communicating well with the levels in their organisations who have the expertise to deal with the Internet.

At question time I suggested to Mr. Gowing that perhaps he needs to "get out more" and talk to people in organisations who are conversant with the Internet, rather than with senior leaders who are not. My own experience is that senior people (cabinet ministers, generals and their civilian equivalents) may not be familiar with the Internet, but can learn what they need to know quickly.

Mr. Gowing appears to be developing the theme of his similarly named 2009 work published by Oxford University: "Skyful of lies and black swans: the new tyranny of shifting information power in crises".  After his presentation I read the work and it has much to say which is of value. The central argument is that the Internet and mobile devices have resulted in formation becoming more widely available more quickly and outside the control of governments and other formal organisations. He argued that this was catching organisations unawares. However, that might have been the case twenty years ago, but seems unlikely in 2009 and certainly not the case in 2014. Organisations and governments have adapted to the Internet and mobile based information (I know this as I have helped the process in the Australian government and some other organisations). There is an ongoing challenge for formal organisations and particularly those which have exercised power, or made profits, from control and dissemination of information. Some organisations have prospered in the Internet environment, some just coped and some failed.

There is continuing work going on to adapt organisations to the Internet and the Internet to organisations. Much of this work is commercial-in-confidence or state classified secrets, but some is public. One example is the DARPA Social Media in Strategic Communication (SMISC) research, which seeks to counter Internet based propaganda by terrorist groups and governments hostile to the interests of the USA. For Australia I have proposed a CyberWarfare Battalion (ACWB).

Reference

Gowing, N. (2009). "Skyful of lies" and black swans: the new tyranny of shifting information power in crises. Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism, University of Oxford.

Information Power in Crises

Nik Gowing, BBC World News, will speak on "Skyful of Lies and Black Swans: Who Controls Shifting Information Power in Crises?" at the Australian National University in Canberra, 5pm, 12 August 2014.
The public information space has been turned on its head. But few at the highest levels of power are willing to realise that its new capacity to disrupt threatens their reputation or brand. There is a reluctance to learn from the destabilising experiences of others in multiple fields and locations. This presentation and discussion focus on the new executive fragilities and policy implications for government ministers, civil servants, defence and security agencies plus corporate institutions and NGO’s from the new matrix of real-time information flows and transparency created especially by the explosion of social media. The new digital connectivity and IT realities are disruptive game changers. They challenge mercilessly the inadequacy of the structures of power to respond both with effective impact and in a timely way.

As vulnerabilities increase, mindsets and systemic behaviour lag behind these new realities. After BP’s Gulf of Mexico disaster, the Japan earthquake catastrophe and nuclear disaster, terror attacks and natural disasters, plus Libya, Egypt, Tunisia, Syria, Ukraine and multiple concerns about the stability of other regimes, Nik Gowing, main presenter for BBC World News, presents an overview and update on the implications for power of his peer-reviewed Skyful of Lies analysis. The professional implications are vital leadership issues. Governments, public servants or security officials plus commanders and corporate executives must understand how to embrace effectively the new realities of today's media and public information space. It is far broader and more multi-dimensional, than the vast majority are prepared to realise, let alone concede. Yet it challenges all the conventional assumptions about the nature of power.

Biography: Nik Gowing has been a main presenter for the BBC’s international 24-hour news channel BBC World News, since 1996. He has presented The Hub with Nik Gowing, BBC World Debates, Dateline London , plus location coverage of major global stories. For 18 years he worked at ITN where he was bureau chief in Rome and Warsaw, and Diplomatic Editor for Channel Four News (1988-1996). He has been a member of the councils of Chatham House (1998–2004), the Royal United Services Institute (2005–present), and the Overseas Development Institute (2007-2014), the board of the Westminster Foundation for Democracy including vice chair (1996-2005), and the advisory council at Wilton Park (1998-2012 ). In 1994 he was a fellow at the Joan Shorenstein Barone Center in the J. F. Kennedy School of Government, Harvard University. Nik has extensive reporting experience over three decades in diplomacy, defence and international security. He also has a much sought-after analytical expertise on the failures to manage information in the new transparent environments of conflicts, crises, emergencies and times of tension. His peer-reviewed study at Oxford University is “Skyful of Lies and Black Swans”. It predicts and identifies the new vulnerability, fragility and brittleness of institutional power in the new all-pervasive public information space. It can be downloaded free online after registration. Nic was awarded an honorary doctorate by Exeter University in 2012 for both his cutting edge study and distinguished career in international journalism. He has just been appointed a Visiting Professor at Kings College, London.

Tuesday, July 22, 2014

Government Internet Censorship in Canberra

Jillian York, Director of International Freedom of Expression for the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF), is speaking on a panel "Unfriended? Social Media and Government Censorship in Times of Violence" at the Australian National University in Canberra.

One comment from the panel was that Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant (ISIL),are sophisticated Internet users, including pictures of kittens posed alongside weapons to promote their campaign. The problem for the Iraqi government is that they have made use of the state media for partisan purposes and so not in a position to appear credible online.

Another panellist commented that Facebook in particular to inflame sectarian violence in Myanmar, but also to counter it. They advocated the Myanmar government censoring the Internet.

One panellist pointed out India limited users to five SMS messages per day during times of communal tension.

What I found curious was that all the panellists treated the Internet as a given fixed thing. In fact the Internet was something which was invented and is being modified continuously. Perhaps the question should be under what circumstances the government can censor citizens communication. With the increasing convergence of communications there is a risk that all communication could be monitored and censored by government. Also as one panellist mentioned, there is censorship by companies acting on what they believe to be local laws and customs. 

It would be feasible to build a national communications system which would filter what each citizen sees and hears on their computer, telephone, TV and newspaper, but would this be a good idea? In effect the government, or a company, could impose what is effectively what is electronic house arrest on every citizen, all the time.

One panellist  pointed out that a minority of citizens in developed nations have access to the Internet and so are cut off from its benefits, even before censorship.
Do governments ever have the right to cut off or censor internet access? What about in times of civil unrest? Do companies have an obligation to work with governments in such situations, or an obligation to refuse? In a region regularly beset by communal violence and political unrest, but with some of the fastest growing populations of internet users in the world, the rights and responsibilities of companies such as twitter, facebook and youtube are not clear-cut. Last month, for example, Thailand’s newest government ordered facebook to be temporarily shut down amid a wave of protests, blunting the tools of pro-democracy campaigners. But in Iraq, the government recently shifted a 17-day social media ban imposed to disrupt brutal media offensives initiated by armed militants sweeping towards Baghdad. In Papua New Guinea, meanwhile, recent unrest has seen several government members argue that access to the internet should be cut off to avoid rumour, gossip and violence.

Join us for a panel discussion on the complex rights and responsibilities of internet companies on Tuesday 22 July, featuring Jillian York, Director of International Freedom of Expression for the Electronic Frontier Foundation. Other panel participants include: Dr Nicholas Farrelly and Usman Hamid Abdul of the Department of Political and Social Change; Jacky Sutton, of the Centre for Arab and Islamic Studies; and Dr Sarah Logan, of State, Society and Governance in Melanesia.

Thursday, July 17, 2014

Discussion of Government Internet Censorship in Canberra

Jillian York, Director of International Freedom of Expression for the Electronic Freedom Foundation, will speak on "Unfriended? Social Media & Government Censorship in Times of Violence" at the Australian National University in Canberra, 1:00 PM, 22 July 2014.
Do governments ever have the right to cut off or censor internet access? What about in times of civil unrest? Do companies have an obligation to work with governments in such situations, or an obligation to refuse? In a region regularly beset by communal violence and political unrest, but with some of the fastest growing populations of internet users in the world, the rights and responsibilities of companies such as twitter, facebook and youtube are not clear-cut. Last month, for example, Thailand’s newest government ordered facebook to be temporarily shut down amid a wave of protests, blunting the tools of pro-democracy campaigners. But in Iraq, the government recently shifted a 17-day social media ban imposed to disrupt brutal media offensives initiated by armed militants sweeping towards Baghdad. In Papua New Guinea, meanwhile, recent unrest has seen several government members argue that access to the internet should be cut off to avoid rumour, gossip and violence.

Join us for a panel discussion on the complex rights and responsibilities of internet companies on Tuesday 22 July, featuring Jillian York, Director of International Freedom of Expression for the Electronic Freedom Foundation. Other panel participants include: Dr Nicholas Farrelly and Usman Hamid Abdul of the Department of Political and Social Change; Jacky Sutton, of the Centre for Arab and Islamic Studies; and Dr Sarah Logan, of State, Society and Governance in Melanesia.

Friday, December 16, 2011

Converging media and Internet rules impossible

The Australian Government's Convergence Review has issued an "Convergence Review Interim Report" on media and communications regulation in Australia (27 pages PDF). The difficulty for such a review is that not only have different forms of mass media converged, with print, radio and TV all now using the Internet, but so have personal communications. Media regulation was based on the assumption that a publicly owned resource (such as radio spectrum) or expensive capital equipment (a printing press) was needed for mass communication. The state could therefore regulate the media by controlling access to the communications means and could justify this by the effect that the mass communication may have on the public. But now that print, radio and TV companies are using the same Internet technology available to the general public, these rules do not make much sense. If one person views on-line content I make, I probably am not a media company, but if thousands do, a I? If the media company tailors it product for every individual viewer, is this still the mass media?

As an example, there are rules about what time of day and week alcohol advertisements can be shown on broadcast TV. These are designed to avoid school age children being exposed to the ads. But Internet distribution is not time zone based and so such a rule would be hard to enforce.

Google label their AdWords ads with a family status: "family safe" "non-family safe" or "adult." The definitions differ based on country.
Also Google have some curious rules about alcohol: "Google AdWords allows alcoholic beverages like beer, cider, sake, wine, and champagne, but we don't allow hard alcohol and liquor".

However, this form of regulation would is well down the slippery slope of web censorship. Many will think keeping alcohol ads from children is a good thing, but the same system can be used to ban ads for "change your religion", "votes for women", "opposition political party" and "democracy".Link

From the review report:

Contents
Foreword iv
1. Introduction 1
2. A new regulator for the digital economy 2
3. The removal of content licences 4
4. Content Service Enterprises 5
5. Spectrum allocation and management 6
6. Diversity 8
7. Competition 10
8. Promoting Australian content 11
9. Promoting local and community content 14
10. Public broadcasting 15
11. Content standards 16
12. Legislative structure and implementation 17
13. Conclusion & Summary 19
Appendix One: Examples of redundant regulation 20
Appendix Two: Convergence Review Principles 21
Appendix Three: Glossary and Abbreviations 22

...

13. Conclusion & Summary
This report sets out a vision for the future. The move away from an industry and platform specific focus will create a new framework that is technology-neutral and is adaptable and flexible. These reforms will result in reduced, more effective regulation.


The implementation of the recommendations outlined in this report will provide a new regulatory ecosystem underpinning the digital economy. The recommendations in this report should to be viewed as an integrated package of reforms. They are designed to work together covering the key issues: who regulates, what is
regulated and the intended outcomes.

The Committee expects a robust debate around the recommendations and their implementation. While stakeholders submitted different views about preferred outcomes, the overarching theme expressed during consultations was the urgent need for fundamental change.


Summary of key features of new policy framework

  • A new regulator for the digital economy
  • Removal of content‐related licences
  • A platform‐neutral regulatory framework focused on Content Service Enterprises
  • Diversity and competition measures for the converged market
  • Reform of spectrum allocation and management
  • Platform‐neutral rules for Australian content
  • Promotion of local content and support for innovation in its delivery
  • Updated charters for ABC and SBS

...

From: Convergence Review Interim Report, Australian Government, 2011.

Monday, August 16, 2010

Censorship Not Part of the Future of Thinking in the Information Age

Professor Cathy N. Davidson (Duke University) is speaking on "The Future of Thinking in an Information Age" at the Australian National University in Canberra. She started by quoting web originator Tim Berners-Lee as saying that the web is not done yet (there is more design to be done) and that it is a web of human knowledge and social phenomenon. Also she emphasised the importance of mobile devices in the future of the web. She drew a distinction between the Internet and the Web, which many fail to understand. She argues that the web should not be centrally controlled by government.

The professor argued that the Information age has a new Epistemology. Perhaps proving the point, as I was looking up the word "Epistemology" in the Wikipedia, she used the Wikipedia as an example. However, it was not clear to me how the Wikipedia is different to what came before, as it is simply the translation of an encyclopedia to the online environment. While the Wikipedia allows for many people to compose entries, it still assumes there is only one definition for each term: it assumes the old fashioned notion of one view of the "truth".

Also as I was typing the above there was an SMS message telling me there is a 6pm Public Lecture "Beyond the Spin: Leaders, parties and politics, Beyond the Spin: ANU / ABC Federal Election Discussion Series". This was taking place a few hundred metres away on the campus. The political process also seems mired in the idea that society needs to have a competition where one view wins and the rest loose.

The professor argued that many current ideas of knowledge and education are from the previous machine age and not the new "webby" age. The professor seemed to assume that the normal way education was done at a university was with very large classes of students doing rote learning, followed by multiple choice tests. Perhaps Duke University is behind when it comes to education, compared to places like ANU. As an example I have attended today a seminar at ANU on Blended Delivery, answered some queries from my online students, met with someone from Iceland who wants to research how to use the Internet for international relations. That is a normal day: no large classes, no multiple choice tests.

The professor gave examples of new pedagogies where the students are consulted on what is in the course. However, I assume this is normal part of any course at a genuine educational institution. As an example, today one of my Green ICT students argued that the government carbon emission standard I asked them to use was not appropriate, so I replied they could meet an alternative standard, provided they could justify it.

While I agree with Professor Davidson there is scope for more student input on assessment, I do not agree that external standards can be abandoned. Where universities are training to do a job, such as engineering, the community is entitled to expect external standards to be met, otherwise lives will be lost as a result.

Professor Davidson asked (rhetorically) how we train people to be good online citizens. This seems a very easy question, with an obvious answer: we teach the students how to read and write online as part of courses. In my Green ICT course there are weekly online forums. In the first few weeks, I spend most of my time helping the students learn to communicate professional in this environment.

Unfortunately Professor Davidson used the example of coordinating orders for pizza as an example of a collaborative application online. The ordering of pizza has been an example used since the dawn of the Internet and it is about decade past where this is a useful example.

It may be that I am being a little to harsh on Professor Davidson as the ANU is a relatively well equipped university and hosts institutions which helped develop Internet technology. As a result I can tend to take access and knowledge of the technology, particularly for education, for granted. But it seemed a little odd for the Professor to be standing in a fully Internet connected teaching room, with several of the audience reporting live online using the university WFi system and telling us how universities are not using the Internet.

Much of what Professor Davidson had to say seemed to reflect a very narrow US-centric view of education and the use of technology. The Professor was assuming that Australia had an education system like the USA using techniques such as multiple choice tests for testing. It is unfortunate that the Professor did not look at how education is done in Australia and other parts of the world, to see what lessons could be learned from it.

Professor Davidson argued that most current education systems were invented in the last 100 years to support the industrial age. On the face of it, this sounds like nonsense. Perhaps after I look at what evidence the Professor has collected I will change my mind, but I suspect not. I have walked the ancient way at Delphi, used Cybercafes in Mapusa Markets in India and seen a gold auction in the Grand Bazaar of Istanbul what struck me was that much has not changed in thousands of years. New technology has been added to ancient ways of working.

As you can perhaps tell, I was not very impressed with Professor Davidson's prepared presentation. However, question time was much better. One point which came out was that Professor Davidson is opposed to the US system for assessing each k-12 student with a standardised test. This is essentially the system adopted by the current Australian Prime Minister with "MySchool".

Professor Davidson pointed out that email tends not to be productive, as there is a mass of undifferentiated material. However the Professor was incorrect in saying that systems to fix this have not been built. There are systems routinely used, such as for Learning Management Systems, which provide ways to handle messages.

Monday, July 26, 2010

Future of the Internet in Australia

I will be speaking on "Future of the Internet in Australia" at the Australian National University, 29 July 2010. Registration is not required and the talk is free, but you can RSVP via Facebook to help the organisers guage numbers and join in the online discussion.
The Political Academy ANU
Topic: Future of the Internet in Australia
Speaker: Tom Worthington FACS CP HLM, Adjunct Senior Lecturer, ANU School of Computer Science
Time: Thursday 29 July 2010, 6:00pm
Location: College of Business and Economics (Building 26C), the Australian National University, Canberra

Abstract: The Internet is increasingly a part of business, education, entertainment and government. But what can we do about the negative aspects of objectionable and criminal activities online? Everyone wants free access to information, but worries about how this may adversely effect another group: children and others at risk. Tom Worthington argues that perfect Internet regulation is not politically or technically feasible and that education is the answer.

Uniquely, Tom Worthington was selected to explain what the Internet was to the Australian Senate. For this and other work he was elected a fellow Australian Computer Society. Tom teaches green ICT and web ethics at the ANU and was invited to China to advise on how to put the Beijing Olympics on the web. Come along and discuss with Tom some of the social ramifications of the Internet, censorship, self censorship, Google and governance.

See also:

Monday, June 21, 2010

Kogan Internet Filter Spoof

Kogan have produced a video about a fictional product, the "PORTECTOR Internet Portal Filter". This uses humour to point up problems with Senator Conroy's proposals for internet filtering.

There are real security appliances which are designed to protect homes, businesses and schools from unwanted content. Perhaps Kogan should source some of these and offer them for sale.

Wednesday, May 12, 2010

Canberra has highest Internet use

The ABS reports that the ACT continues to have the largest proportion of households with computers (88%) and Internet access (82%). The ABS seems to be courting controversy by reporting that "The majority of ACT households have taken steps to protect their children's personal safety while using the Internet at home...". This contradicts the position of the Minister for Communications that mandatory censorship of the Internet by the government is required to protect children.

Thursday, January 14, 2010

Google ceasing censorship due to Chinese hacking attacks

Google has announced they will cease censoring web search results in Chin. I was just interviewed about this by ABC Sunshine Coast Radio. The reason given by Google to review its business operations in China are sophisticated attacks originating from China attempting to access Gmail accounts of human rights activists. While the Google announcement does not so in plain language, Google is clearly accusing the Chinese government of attacking its systems. Google has about one third of Chinese search revenue and this is a significant market to give up. What might be also significant is the effect on China of the loss of access to Google, if the Chinese government decides to block the site. It will be an interesting economic experiment to see how quickly other companies move in to fill the vacuum and if the lack of Google impedes the Chinese economy.

ps: I had top declare my interest in the radio interview, as I have Google AdSense advertising on my web pages and earn money from them.