Showing posts with label USQ. Show all posts
Showing posts with label USQ. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 23, 2013

Mobile Learning Research Project

USQ are conducting a Mobile Learning Research Project as part of their Digital Futures Project. The first question is: "What is mobile learning". I filled in a survey form, but could not say much more than m-learning involved a hand held computer and some form of education (formal or informal). But I guess you could do mobile learning through the computer in the dashboard in your car (which is mobile, but not hand held). In my view mobile learning does not imply a different style of learning, although the places and times you use a mobile device are going to require much shorter periods of study, than sitting at a desk.

Wednesday, November 28, 2012

Online Distance Education for the Mature Student

I just attended a USQ focus group to get the views of students on technology used by the university (I was a USQ education student for two semesters). The focus group was conducted online via Blackboard Collaborate and worked well. It appears that I am a typical mature student who does not want mobile apps, twitter or Facebook, just ordinary old fashioned Moodle, email, lecture recordings and video conferences. ePortfolios appear to be popular and MOOCs may be appealing as a supplement to normal courses. I urged USQ to keep producing well designed online courses, delivered by well trained staff and not get distracted by e-fads.

Monday, November 12, 2012

University Green IT Guidelines

The University of Southern Queensland (USQ) has issued an "ICT Guideline for Green IT" (30 October 2012). This aims to reduce the USQ’s ICT carbon footprint. Measure include consolidating applications and selection of energy efficient equipment. Recycling to avoid eWaste is also discussed.

No figures on existing emissions or ewaste are given and no targets are set, so the USQ's commitment to ICT Sustainability is questionable. The document is the equivalent of 2 A4 pages and at 159 kbytes is not efficiently formatted, thus wasting ICT resources.
Strategic areas of focus for ICT Services include:
  • Optimise resource usage and reduce waste and inefficient resource application by ensuring that appropriate technologies are chosen to support business requirements.
  • Manage resource consumption and demand through consolidation and virtualisation. Specific initiatives include:
    • Consolidate servers and manage optimised shared virtual infrastructure;
    • Consolidate applications and infrastructure by promoting the use of shared services including cloud computing where appropriate;
    • Build and manage more efficient data centers with a PUE (Power Usage Effectiveness) rating of less than 2.0 and approaching 1.0;
    • Consolidate and reduce the number of computer laboratories to ensure optimal utilisation;
    • Consolidate the number of printers in use and replace these with more efficient larger capacity multi-function printing devices;
    • Improve the ratio of desktop computers to printer ratio.
  • Encourage electronic collaboration through the use of the learning management system, Microsoft
  • SharePoint technologies and other collaboration tools which can improve the collaborative effort and effectiveness of all staff and students;
  • Implement new computing infrastructures including increased use of mobile devices or thin clients, as replacements for more intensive, less flexible computing devices.
  • Safe and responsible disposal and recycling of ICT equipment and eWaste (Refer also to ICT Procurement Guidelines);
  • Consider energy efficiency in technology selection and acquisition. Improvements in sustainable procurement including procurement of green equipment such as Electronic Product Environmental
  • Assessment Tool (EPEATTM)1 registered desktop computers, laptops and monitors or purchasing products with a high ENERGY STAR® 2 and EPEATTM rating;
  • Centralisation of ICT procurement, deployment and disposal assists with improving asset management, reuse and recycling across the University;
  • Provide alternatives to travel by using remote communication technologies.

What can you do as an individual?

  • Minimise energy consumption of idle devices, specifically desktop computers and mobile devices (ie turn off computer equipment when not in use).
  • Safe disposal and recycling of ICT equipment and eWaste (Refer also to ICT Procurement Guidelines).
  • Reduce unnecessary travel by using remote communication technologies. Reduce unnecessary printing.

Green Printing

The University continues to investigate a number of specific strategies to reduce the amount of unnecessary printing including:
  • All networked printers and multi-function devices are configured (by default) to print duplex.
  • Multi-function devices enable greater use of scanning features rather than printing.
  • Meeting agendas and associated material are published online to reduce the requirement to print meeting material. ...
From:  ICT Guideline for Green IT, Executive Director, ICT Services, University of Southern Queensland, 30 October 2012

Friday, September 28, 2012

On-line Professional Education for ANU


This is in response to a media report on proposed changes to the Australian National University (ANU) higher education portfolio  (Nairn, 2012). While supporting the changes, I suggest ANU could also continue to offer an education program.

As I understand it, ANU is considering phasing out its Graduate Certificate and Master of Higher Education. In their place e-learning would be used to improve staff skills in teaching, supervision and administration. Those staff wanting formal qualifications in these fields would  be encouraged to undertake programs at universities with specialist programmes.

In making these changes, I suggest ANU could continue to offer formal professional skills courses to retain its position as a leading university.

Professional Skills Modules for Staff and Students

The skills which ANU academics need, to be able to teach and to supervise research, are also required by professionals in the workplace. Professionals are required to take charge of their own learning, as well as mentor, teach and supervise staff. These are skills which do not come naturally, requiring formal training and testing.

In place of "teaching" courses for staff, I suggest ANU offer modules in professional skills to all postgraduate students in all programs. This will provide sufficient student numbers to make such training viable. The same modules can be undertaken by ANU staff and also used in formal courses.

As has been demonstrated with my course "ICT Sustainability" (offered by ANU as COMP7310), it is possible to bridge the divide between professional education and the requirements of higher education (Worthington, 2012). This shows it is possible to deliver quality education to professionals in the work place, in the same on-line class as postgraduate university students.

As well as being offered to computer science and engineering postgraduate students at ANU, COMP7310 is also available through ANU Graduate Studies Select. The flexibility of that program offers a way for ANU to continue to offer an education program.

Education Program via Graduate Studies Select

ANU Graduate Studies Select allows students to choose from courses across the ANU and allied universities. The ANU Graduate Certificate and Master of Higher Education could be replaced with Graduate Studies Select equivalents. Students would undertake some basic education courses at other institutions and advanced courses at ANU.

In anticipation of changes in ANU's education portfolio, in 2011 I arranged with my academic adviser to undertake the first half of the ANU Graduate Certificate in Higher Education, by distance education. I selected two on-line courses offered by the ANU's alliance partner, the University of Southern Queensland (USQ): Assessment and Online Pedagogy. These proved a good fit with ANU's own course in Research Supervision (EDUC8004). This custom program in Research-Led Education, could be a model for ANU.

Teach Students and Staff How to Manage Their Own Learning

The ANU already offers numerous on-line and face-to-face short training modules and development activities for staff and students. I suggest these could be incorporated into formal courses which teach students and staff how to manage their own learning. The courses would teach the use of tools such as e-portfolios, to assemble the evidence of skills gained, to obtain formal course credit.

ANU cannot simply rely on short courses and those of other institutions. To retain its status as a leading university, the ANU needs to continue its own research into how education and research are undertaken and to impart that new knowledge to ANU students and staff.

Disclaimer

These views are those of the author and do not necessarily represent those of the ANU, or any other organisation.

Tom Worthington FACS CP
Consulting Computer Professional, and
Adjunct Lecturer, Research School of Computer Science, The Australian National University

References

Nairn, J. (2012, 2012-09-18T14:23:03+1000). More jobs to go as ANU cuts courses, Current, ABC News. Retrieved from http://www.abc.net.au/news/2012-09-18/anu-cuts-more-courses/4268038?section=act

Worthington, T. (2012). A Green computing professional education course online: Designing and delivering a course in ICT sustainability using Internet and eBooks. Paper presented at the Computer Science & Education (ICCSE), 2012 7th International Conference on, Melbourne, Australia. Retrieved from http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/stamp/stamp.jsp?tp=&arnumber=6295070&isnumber=6295013

Tuesday, August 07, 2012

Doctoral Education in the 21st Century

Having completed courses in Assessment and online pedagogy at the University of Southern Queensland (USQ), it was time to move back to the Australian National University, to complete my postgraduate certificates in tertiary teaching, and study research supervision. The idea is to apply what I have learned about running course online to supervising research students.

What is a doctoral degree?

Before looking at issues with doctoral education, I needed to understand the basics of what a doctorate is. However, this proved difficult, as most academic witting assumes the reader knows what a traditional doctorate is and only describes divergence from this.

According to the Wikipedia, a doctorate is:

'... an academic degree or professional degree that in most countries qualifies the holder to teach in a specific field... from the Latin docere, meaning "to teach.'.
This is not a very useful description. The OED more usefully defines a Doctor as:

A person who, in any faculty or branch of learning, has attained to the highest degree conferred by a University; a title originally implying competency to teach such subject or subjects, but now merely regarded as a certificate of the highest proficiency therein.

A report to DEST in 2002 (Research Training in Doctoral Programs, by McWilliam, Taylor, Thomson, Green, Maxwell, Wildy Simons), quoted the definition of a professional doctorate from the Australian Council of Deans and Directors of Graduate Studies:

‘a program of research and advanced study, which enables the candidate to make a significant contribution to knowledge and practice in their professional context [and in which]…the candidate may also contribute more generally to scholarship within a discipline or field of study’ (CADDGS, 1998: 1).

Also I recently attended the University of Canberra workshop on Supervising a doctorate by published works (by publication). At this there was discussion of a PHD by coursework. What is evident from all this was that a doctoral education will likely involve coursework, publication and research, but the proportions may differ between types of doctorate.

National groupings and organizations

The Bologna Process (or "Bologna Accords") describes standardization of higher education qualifications by most European countries, plus some of Asia. Australian higher education qualifications come under the Bologna Accords through signing of the Convention on the Recognition of Qualifications concerning Higher Education in the European Region (the "Lisbon Recognition Convention") in 2002. Before reading this I thought "Bologna" was a type of sausage also known as "baloney". wink

The Bologna model has a three level model of degrees and the amount of full time study required for them:

  1. Undergraduate: two years
  2. Masters: two years,
  3. Doctoral: three years.

The major differences with existing Australian degrees, is at the undergraduate level, where there may be a fourth "Honors" year for professional qualifications. It is likely that the popularity of an honors year will decline with the Bologna Process, in favor of a two year masters.

Role of Professions in National and International Educational Standards

It should be noted that governments are not the only ones involved in international standardization of qualifications. My own professional body, the Australian Computer Society, is involved in setting educational standards, through accreditation of ICT courses at Australian universities (including ANU). ACS also carries out Migration Skills Assessment for the Australian Government (I wrote the Green ICT test for this assessment). Through the International Federation for Information Processing (IFIP) the IP3 initiative has set an international standard at the postgraduate level for IT, equivalent to an Australian graduate certificate (IP3: Progress Towards a Global ICT Profession, Johnson, 2010). My ICT Sustainability course is part of the Australian certification for the global program. However, ICT professional recognition of qualifications does not extend to masters or PHD level. The ACS Fellow grade of membership is defined in a similar way to a professional doctorate.

Bologna Model at University of Melbourne

Professor Iven Mareels, Dean of Engineering at University of Melbourne gave an overview of the changes to engineering and computer science programs brought about by the "Melbourne University Model", which is in part a response to the Bologna Model, in a talk he gave at ICCSE 2012 (which I attended). With this system, students choose from one of only six undergraduate degrees (engineering and computer science students would normally undertake a Bachelor of Science).

Unlike undergraduate degrees from other Australian universities, the Melbourne degrees do not meet the requirements of professional bodies, such as ACS, for entry. Students are expected to undertake a further 18 months study for CS or two years for Engineering to complete a masters.

Professor Mareels commented that this program was intended to meet the needs of international students. Many international students were undertaking the undergraduate degree in their own country and then coming to Melbourne University for the masters.

The courses are part student directed problem based learning. However, Professor Mareels commented that traditional lecture based courses have to be used in part, due to their lower cost. I though this a curious comment, as it is possible to design cost effective student directed problem based-courses by using on-line techniques.

Issues

The Research Supervision Global Developments used by ANU, Oxford University and others, lists seven issues:

  1. National groupings and organizations
  2. Focus on timely completions and research training
  3. Increased focus on quality assurance
  4. Increased mobility and transport
  5. The ubiquity of English
  6. Technology and changes in the nature of knowledge and research
  7. National security and terrorism issues

There does not appear to be any common theme to these issues. The first three topics (Internationalization, Professionalism and Quality) appear to naturally group together being about the process of standardizing degree processes. The other four topics (Mobility, English, Technology and Security) do not.

Some Readings

Auriol, L. (2007). Labour market characteristics and international mobility of doctorate holders: Results for seven countries. Paris: OECD.

The OECD and UNESCO compared doctorate holders in Argentina, Australia, Canada, Germany, Portugal, Switzerland and the United-States. They found Germany and Switzerland had two to three times the number of doctorate holders, as a proportion of the workforce, as Australia, Canada or the USA. Germany has 2% of the workforce with doctorates, versus 0.78% for Australia. This suggests scope for more Australian PHDs. The report also points out that the USA has many foreign PHD working and that these contribute a significant amount of the USA's research output. There may be some lessons for Australia's overseas education markets of India and China in this.

Department of Education, Science and Training (2006). The Bologna Process and Australia: Next steps.

Note that this document was not available from the DEST website, but is in the Google cache.

DEST list the objectives of the Bologna Process as:

  1. Easily readable and comparable degrees - the foremost tools for achieving this are the European Credit Transfer System (ECTS) and the Diploma Supplement.
  2. Uniform degree structures - initially, it was agreed that the degree structure would be mainly based on a two-cycle model. The first cycle, lasting a minimum of three years, ends in a Bachelor-level degree. Masters degrees are the second cycle. There has since been agreement (Berlin 2003) to the inclusion of third cycle degrees (doctorates) within the Bologna framework.
  3. Establishment of a system of credits - such as in the ECTS system - many countries do not have a system of study credits and determine their degrees only in years or semesters. The objective of a establishing a system of credits is to promote widespread student mobility.
  4. Increased mobility - obstacles to the effective mobility of students, teachers, researchers and administrative staff will be removed.
  5. Promotion of European co-operation in quality assurance with a view to developing comparable criteria and methodologies - the European Network of Quality Assurance in Higher Education plays a key role in this.
  6. Promotion of the European dimension in higher education - closer international cooperation and networks; language and cultural education.

While DEST refers to promotion of European educational objectives, the same clearly apply to Australia. The "Diploma Supplement" mentioned is an EU/UNESCO initiative to provide a standardized mode detailed description of each graduate's qualifications. The 2007 Review of Higher Degree Research at ANU recommended the ANU testamur be reviewed with a view to incorporating such supplement. ANU is now issuing eTranscripts through the company Digitary, which was setup up by Dublin City University. But it is not clear if ANU is using the system to provide Bologna Process compliant Diploma Supplement.

Other nations hacve worked on internationalization of their higher education, such as Malaysia, with the "Internationalization Policy for Higher Education Malaysian 2011" (Ministry of Higher Education, Malaysia, 2011).

Enders, J. (2005). Border crossings: Research training, knowledge dissemination and the transformation of academic work. Higher Education, 49(1-2), 119-133.

Enders describes a shift from the Humboldtian to a professional model of education.

Enders points out that many doctoral graduates go on to work in industry, suggesting a need for alternatives to a "doctorate by thesis".

However, I suggest the Humboldtian model, with its emphases on the teacher's role in guiding the student's own research, has strong parallels with modern educational theories. This suggests a way research and coursework could be harmoniously combined in a doctoral program.

McEachern, D. (2004). Postgraduate research re-imagined: A balance between the pursuit of excellences and real world needs of students. In M. Kiley & G. Mullins (Eds.), Quality in postgraduate research: Re-imagining research education (pp. 45-52). Canberra: CELTS University of Canberra.

McEachern supports Australian reforms to the doctoral process, but proposes further changes to examination process, in particular challenging the Australian custom of requiring at least one "overseas" assessor. Also they propose the members of the supervisory panel also be examiners.

McEachern proposes the supervisory panel meet on-line to allow for external experts and suggests the same technology could be used for .a "face-to-face" defense of the thesis. This suggests to me a limited understanding of how on-line technology can be used. On-line courses do not tend to use real-time communication as their primary teaching method. This would be expensive in staff time and also very inconvenient for the staff and students. Similarly it would make more sense to use store-and-forward communication (called "asynchronous" in pedagogy), rather than real-time ("synchronous") for supervision and examination.

Also, before a"face to face" examination is used, any underlying biases in the process need to be considered. As an example, it would not be possible to disguise the gender and identity of the student with a face to face examination. Also poor spoken English may count against the student, even though this is not a criterion for a doctorate.

McEachern discusses the need for computing skills by doctoral candidates, suggesting some skills are needed in databases, informatics, modeling, and simulation. However, my experience as an ICT professional working with other disciplines suggest a more basic level of ICT skills are needed by students, in how to read and write on-line and undertake basic on-line searches. A suitable standard would be the Europe as the European Driver's License (ECDL), also known as the International Computer Driver's License (ICDL).

Also a UK study looked at the research behaviour of higher education research students ("The research behaviour of Generation Y doctoral students" (JISC, 2012). This found that students favoured secondary online sources of information and rarely looked at source data.

McEachern argues for a combination of graduate course work and a thesis, as an option for PHD programs. This is described as being "based on the American model", but does not detail the model further. It is a surprise to me that in 2004 no Australian university was offering a program where the student could undertake coursework as part of a doctorate.

McWilliam, E., Singh, P., & Taylor, P. (2002). Doctoral Education, Danger and Risk Management. Higher Education Research and Development, 21(2), 119-129.

McWilliam, Taylor and Singh's failed in their attempt to "make explicit connections between risk management systems, universities and doctoral education". They use terms such as "danger", "audit" and "risk" with a lack of clarity and precision. Some familiarity with the terminology and techniques of the risk management discipline may have helped the analysis, in particular use of the ISO 31000 series of risk management standards.

Nerad, M. (2006). Globalisation and its impact on research education: Trends and Emerging Best Practices for the Doctorate of the Future. In M. Kiley & G. Mullins (Eds.), Quality in Postgraduate Research: Knowledge creation in testing times (pp. 11-12). Canberra, The Australian National University.

Nerad argues that globalisation of industry has resulted in an increase in demand for knowledge workers with PhDs. The strength of this demand and the global standards in industry has resulted in global competition by companies and countries for personnel with PHDs. It is also argued that this is one motivation for the Bologna Process.

The increase in Chinese PHDs is cited: from 2,556 in 1991, to 12,500 in 2001, with two thirds in science and engineering.

Nerad's analysis of the reasons for the large number of Chinese and Indian PHD students in US universities is equally applicable to Australia. Few local students went on to a doctorate previously, as an undergraduate degree was sufficient for a well paying job in industry. Therefore university turned to overseas students for a poorly of winning and well qualified applicants. As a bonus, these students return more revenue to the university than local ones.

They list eighteen best practices for doctoral education. These could be summarized as:

About the student:

  1. Students will be prepared for careers in research, teaching and industry.
  2. Competitive admission.
  3. Multi-year funding, subject to progress being shown by the student.
  4. Students required to have at least two languages (?).

About the supervisory process by the institution:

  1. A code of practice for supervision.
  2. Multiple supervisors for each student.
  3. Introductory courses on research methods and implications.
  4. Students examined on broad understanding.
  5. Interdisciplinary work
  6. Training in teamwork and project skills.
  7. Dissertation or by publication
  8. Overseas research experience required
  9. International culture in curriculum (?)
  10. Internal formative reviews of doctoral candidates, with external summative examination
  11. "world citizenship education" for students (?)

Between institutions:

  1. Collaborative projects between institutions
  2. International program reviews.
  3. Structured international collaborations on global issues

Most of these best practices for doctoral education would not be controversial. However, some would impose considerable burdens on the student, supervisors and the institution. In particular, the requirement for students to have at least two languages and the requirement for overseas research experience as part of the program would would take up a considerable proportion of the resources available for a PHD. It is difficult enough to find a supervisor for a student without requiring them to speak two languages and to arrange overseas postings.

To lower the cost of internationalizing programs, Sinclair gives the example of the University of Melbourne and University of Washington holding a joint workshop for doctoral students. However, this is not very adventurously cross cultural, with Australia and US institutions speaking (approximately) the same language and having very similar cultures. A more adventurous approach might be to team a Western university with institutions in their target markets of India and China.

Also Sinclair does not discuss the option of bringing students together on-line, rather than face to face. ICT graduates will need to get used to a workplace with personnel around the world who they may rarely, if ever, see in person. So the doctoral education may as well make a virtue of necessity, by using virtual global teams of students and supervisors.

The "Student Perceptions of Research Supervision" (SPORS) asked both the students and their supervisors what is expected and then compared the results. This suggests that a team workplace like imprisonment would benefit the students. The research by CAPA also shows that students collaborating are happier. Also I suggest that programs such as Innovation ACT, that encourage budding inventors, would be of value (the program is incorporated in some Multiversity of Canberra, but not ANU courses).

Sinclair, M. (2004). The pedagogy of 'good' PhD supervision: A national cross-disciplinary investigation of PhD supervision. Canberra: Department of Education Science and Training.

Note that this document was not available from the DEST website, but is in the Google cache.

Sinclair found that the discipline had more effect on how long a PHD took to complete than the university it was undertaken at. The argue that PhD supervision is a form of pedagogy, however the later discussion of the independence and confidence needed by students suggests the terms andragogy, or heutagogy, would be more applicable.

Sinclair's analysis provides some useful ideas for the use of on-line systems to support the supervision process. As an example, the 'hands on' supervisors' warning signals could easily be automated, with an absence of on-line activity by the student aromatically alerting the supervisor.

Perhaps more importantly, the same automated technique could be used to warn of an absence of supervision. The lack of input from a supervisor could first be flagged to their co-supervisors and then to senior academic staff. This process could be extended to be part of the audit process with the most senior levels of the university, external bodies and as a publicly reported performance measure.

Saturday, June 16, 2012

USQ Online Pedagogy Course

This week I completed the course "Online Pedagogy in Practice EDU8114" at the University of Southern Queensland (USQ). This is my second and final unit at USQ, before returning to the Australian National University to complete postgraduate studies in online tertiary teaching and research supervision.

Overall, the pedagogy course was similar to my previous experience with USQ's "Assessment, Evaluation and Learning" (EDU5713). USQ is well set up for supporting online students and my experience of online education was far superior to previous face-to-face studies, as well as superior to other online courses I have taken. The course materials are excellently designed, the tutor was expert and enthusiastic. However at times the tutor seemed overloaded with students.

The course content on the web site did not match the course notes, which caused confusion every week. The course forums were not used by more than a handful of students, as the forums were not integrated with the content and assessment for the course. These are curious flaws in a course which is about designing online courses.

The course content had few surprises for me, as it follows the same approach advocated by Professor Gilly Salmon, which I have used to design a course for the Australian Computer Society. One disappointment was that I selected USQ, partly because Professor Salmon had recently moved there, but she had left by the time my course commenced.

USQ's implementation of the Moodle Learning Management System and Mahara ePortfolio were reliable and effective. Some of the other USQ online systems worked only intermittently or not at all. In particular there were major problems with accessing online readings via the USQ library and I used other university libraries instead of USQ. Wimba Classroom is used for live online classes at USQ, but I was unable to get this to work reliably and had to dial in by phone for every session.

USQ has an excellent centralized online help facility. Unfortunately this system does not cover IT support, for which there is an online system which students do not have access to. So I had the frustrating experience of the IT support system sending me automated messages, inviting me to log-on to a system I was not authorized to use.

USQ is interested in student feedback, but I seemed to get a survey to complete every week, and in the last week of the course, a survey every day. This became more than a little annoying. So each time I got another survey I would lower my rating of USQ. As a result, the surveys may be lowering student satisfaction, rather than helping improve it.

Overall studying at USQ was worthwhile. But contrary to the impression given by TV ads, any university study is hard work and a very frustrating experience much of the time.

What was most useful for me, as a student of education, was the experience of being a student again. As an ICT professional, web designer, university lecturer and an award winning e-learning designer, I though an online course in online pedagogy would be easy. But being a student is not easy and I discovered I still have much to learn about improving the experience for my students.

Thursday, March 29, 2012

Making Sense of On-line Conferences

Greetings from day two of "On-line Learning Futures Festival", being held online world wide. The first session today was moderated from USQ in Queensland, Australia but presented from the University of the South Pacific in Fiji on Shingle teaching. The challenges of teaching in a second or third language with campuses spread over a large part of the Earth are daunting. In 2005 I spent a week in Apia, Samoa, teaching web design for Pacific museum staff and saw some of the challenges first hand.

Yesterday I spent much of the day "at" the futures conference. This caused much amusement from my colleagues, who could see me sitting there with a headset on staring intently at my screen and occasionally furiously tying comments. They threatened to hang a sign on my back saying "Rocket Scientist".

The slides and presentable audio worked very well with the "Blackboard Collaborate" software. The live video of the presenter did not work so well. USQ had only one fixed camera, with no zoom function. As a result there was just a wide shot, showing the presenter and some USQ signs. What would have been better would be to zoom into a closeup of the presenter after the initial introduction.

The text chat function worked well as a back-channel to handle routine questions. There were major problems with audio questions from participants. The moderator had to keep reminding participants to turn on their microphone and turn it off leftwards and their video. I could not understand what the problem was until I tried it myself this morning. Blackboard Collaborate has a button for talk and one for video. However, it is very difficult to tell when these are off or on. This is a serious flaw in the design of the software's interface which caused considerable difficulty.

It is remarkable that the web based video products are little better than the video conferencing software I (tried) to use 15 years ago: at one government agency we had a very expensive video conference system which was mostly used a jukebox for playing CDs at Friday afternoon drinks. ;-)

Recently I have been thinking about the way what educators call synchronous online education can be combined with what they call asynchronous. I concussed that this terms are technically incorrect and misleading. The terms used in computer science of "real-time" and "store and forward" would be clearer. It may be that educators have asked their software developers for a synchronous tool and the result is the problems experienced with Blackboard Collaborate (and similar products). This is partly a technical problem, in that the Internet service can't keep up with the real-time requirements, but partly a conceptual one, in that the face-to-face events being emulated are not purely synchronous.

Most of the time a live event is a combination of near real time and store and forward. That is participants are all listening to one person speak but are each doing other things on their own. I suggest that if the requirements for real-time were relaxed for the software the result would be something which coped with network problems better and also better matched what actually happens at an event.

I suggest that an online collaboration product could be designed which only supports half duplex commutation: that is only one person could talk and transmit at a time. Speakers would have to take turns. Also a delay of at least a second could be inserted between speakers and a time limit would be set for how long someone could talk without interruption (perhaps 30 seconds, being the speaking equivalent of an SMS message). This would make for a very stilted conversation between two people, but not impede a presentation where one person is talking much of the time and then takes questions. The system might also automatically queue the speakers.

Another function would be to have the ability to pause the session, rewind and jump to any point in the past, or the future. Current systems seem to do recording like an old fashioned VCR: you have to wait until the session is over before you can replay the recording. If each audio/video item from a person is limited to less than a minute and there is a pause between each, this would make it possible to compress, index and store each and make it available for instant replay.

Wednesday, March 28, 2012

International Education Conference On-Line

Festival format
Greetings from the "On-line Learning Futures Festival" at University of Southern Queensland (USQ), Australia. I am not actually in Toowomba, where the USQ is, I am in my office in Canberra, taking part online. USQ, University of Leicester (UK) and Athabasca University (Canada) are running this "Follow the Sun", event continuously over the next 48 hours. Each institution is located in a time zone approximately equally located around the world, with each taking turns. Registration if free and you can follow the Twitter stream at: #fts12

The festival is using "Blackboard Collaborate" (previously called Elluminate Live!"). I have used this before and it works fine at dial-up speed on a low cost netbook computer.

It happens I am a student at USQ, studying on-line teaching. My literature search is due in today. Perhaps I can have it very up to date by citing some of the speakers at the conference. But how do I cite an on-line event which is still happening? ;-)

Sunday, March 18, 2012

Progress with On-line Tertiary Teaching for Research-Led Education

After looking at the Postgraduate Certificates in Tertiary Teaching available in Australia and on-line internationally, in November 2011 I commenced study for a "Graduate Certificate in Higher Education" at the Australian National University. Due to my interest in on-line teaching I obtained agreement from my ANU supervisor to take two of the four courses required on-line by distance education. The first course at ANU's alliance partner, the University of Southern Queensland (USQ), November 2011 to February 2012, was "Assessment, Evaluation and Learning " (EDU5713). I recommend this USQ course to those interested in tertiary teaching.

USQ use the same Moodle Learning Management System, which I have used to run postgraduate courses at the ANU and Australian Computer Society. The USQ on-line course is structured as standard university unit, run over a semester, with the same holidays as the on-campus courses. The course typically covers one topic a week, with a chapter in a supplied e-book to read each week, extra readings and on-line weekly forums for discussion. The assessment was by mid semester and end of semester written assignments, submitted online.

Good points of the USQ Course

USQ is set up for distance education and this shows in the excellent on-line support for student queries. Using a central system I can ask a question and this is routed to the relevant area. The system tracks progress with the query and records the details, so I do not need to keep asking the same question of different staff and wondering what is happening.

The enrollment process was relatively simple and quick. There were only two pieces of paper involved in the whole course, with everything else, from start to finish, being online.

The course is provided using Moodle in a similar format to the one I use for my ICT Sustainability course for ANU and ACS students. The assessment tasks and an eBook of notes is provided at the beginning of semester, along with contact details for the tutor. The tutors have both academic and practical experience in education, are enthusiastic and helpful, but at times seem a little overworked (a situation any educator can relate to).

The course topics are revealed on Moodle week by week, with tasks, forums, extra readings and help with the assessment. This process helps prompt busy part time students to keep working, while avoiding overloading them with detail.

The assessment tasks are realistic and relevant to those teaching at university. I have already been able to use work from my assignments in my own teaching (and prepared a conference paper from the assignment material).

Areas for Improvement

The USQ course notes are excellent. These have a brief summary of terms and concepts and introduction to the literature, along with exercises and suggested readings. But with my first course the notes cut out half way through and just a collection of web links where provided for the remaining weeks. The notes cutting out made me feel a bit lost.

While the text of the course notes are well formatted, some of the diagrams are unreadable, as they were provided as low resolution bitmap images. However, in many cases the diagrams were derived from published works and references were included, so I could find a readable original.

The course provides extensive suggested readings and these are offered in electronic form with links to the university library. However, about three times as many readings as it is feasible for a student to read are provided. Many of the electronic documents provided by the university are difficult to read. I got into the habit of not using the links provided to the university library and instead looking for papers online and books in other university libraries.

Some documents provided are scanned in from paper, with the pages skewed and marked with highlighter pen, making them hard to read. The university also uses an eBook service which provides digitally created documents, but these appear to have then been converted into bitmap images to prevent piracy. The quality of the documents on my screen were so poor that I could not comfortably read the materials. Instead I located the books in local Canberra university libraries (with excellent service provided by the libraries of ANU, University of Canberra, ADFA and Australian Catholic University). In most cases I read the paper copies of the books, but in some cases eBook versions superior to those provided with the course were available from other libraries.

The course notes include questions for students to discuss in on-line forums. However, there was little participation by the students. The lack of student discussion may be because there are no marks awarded for it.

It was difficult to find where to post forum contributions to, as the forum names did not always not match the topics in the notes.

While the USQ tutors help when asked, there is no regular individual feed-back to students as part of the course format. Communication with the tutor was by email, without the use of the Dialogue tool built into Moodle. As a result, course messages could get lost in amongst other email. USQ provide a Google Gmail account for each student, which may not meet Australian privacy standards.

There was an additional $15 fee at the end of the course for a paper copy of the results. No electronic certified copies are offered and the paper transcript lacks effective non-copying features.

Overall, these are relatively mild criticisms, with the USQ course far superior to the formal postgraduate tertiary education I have previously undertaken, both online and face-to-face. For comparison, see:
  1. Reflections of an Online Student, Parts 1 to 6, August 2010
  2. Learning University Teaching, June 2011

Saturday, February 11, 2012

Director Needed for Australian Digital Futures Institute

The Australian Digital Futures Institute requires an Executive Director. The ADFI is based at University of Southern Queensland and the director would be appointed a Professor for five years. The Institute is funded by the federal government to research the future of learning, teaching, research, knowledge construction and creative expression. There is a detailed Position Description.
ADFI is a research institute for the future of learning, teaching, research, knowledge construction and creative expression. It aims to create and influence USQ’s future through a variety of drivers and achievements, including building ways, platforms and processes by which the staff and students of USQ can engage. The missions and themes of mobility, openness and digital community underpin the Institute’s future directions. ADFI provides a highly creative and collaborative environment, and will play a significant role in two of USQ’s key projects for which significant external funding has recently been obtained –the Digital Futures Collaborative Research Network (CRN) and the USQconnected Project.

The fundamental objective of the CRN scheme is to help build research capacity in Australia’s regional, newer and implicitly less research intensive universities, in an area nominated by the University. USQ chose Digital Futures as its theme, firstly to complement the University’s broader digital first strategy which encompasses all its learning and teaching, and secondly to build an institutional research capacity in digital futures.

USQ was recently successful in securing approximately $50M in funding from the federal government as part of its Strategic Adjustment Fund (SAF). USQ’s SAF project has four main elements which, when combined, create a ‘package’ of expanded learning via online, on-campus and blended mode. Each element expands and enriches USQ’s existing participation reach through stronger and more engaging pathways, collaborations, programs and platforms. The USQconnected project will facilitate a step change for USQ’s move towards best practice blended delivery of student support and services as well as teaching and learning. It will put in place a framework that will enable the on-going enhancement as well as value-adding innovation of that practice. ADFI, via the Executive Director, will have significant input into and impact on the USQconnected project, as the University continues to focus on the enhanced delivery of the student learning journey experience with the capacity for continuous improvement and innovation. ...

From: Position Description: Executive Director and Professor, Australian Digital Futures Institute, USQ, 2012

Wednesday, January 11, 2012

Online Learning Futures Festival

Festival formatThe "On-line Learning Futures Festival" is a 48 hour continuous global on-line conference, starting 28 March 2012. The event will "Follow the Sun", at University of Southern Queensland (Australia), University of Leicester (UK) and Athabasca University (Canada). Registration if free.

The festival is using "Blackboard Collaborate" (previously called Elluminate Live!"). I have used this before and got it to work with as little as 28.8 kbps.

The "Hacking for Humanity" event at UNSW in 2011 used a similar time zone format. It started in Australia and then we handed off to other locations in turn, around the world for the next two days.
... In exploring the conference theme of futures for knowledge, keynote speakers and discipline practioners will be invited to share and examine the priorities for their subjects with colleagues from a learning and teaching background.
What will individual disciplines look like in 2025? What are the priorities that need to be taught to students in the years to come? What can we learn from current use of technology in teaching, and what lies over the horizon?
Over 48 hours and from three continents, keynote speakers from 12 disciplines will highlight what for them are the priorities in their subject areas before we move onto further elaboration in moderated discussions and technological showcases. ...
From: "Festival Format", Learning Futures Festival, University of Leicester, 2011
Link

Tuesday, January 10, 2012

Digital Futures Project

The Australian National University (ANU) , University of Southern Queensland (USQ), and the University of South Australia (UniSA) are collaborating on a $9M Digital Futures Project. The project aims to research social and policy challenges in boosting participation in higher education through technology rich learning environments. This part of the federal Government's Collaborative Research Networks (CRN) program, which aims to boost research at small regional universities by teaming them with large city ones. This project will research Mobility, Openness and Digital Communities. ANUand USQ previously collaborated on an Engineering Hubs and Spokes Project for teaching undergraduates using blended learning. ANU and USQ have an alliance for teaching and research. Currently I am studying Research-Led Education via a program at ANU, including courses provided by USQ.

Monday, November 21, 2011

Open Access for On-Line Education

Last week I commenced the course Assessment, Evaluation and Learning EDU5713, at University of Southern Queensland, via e-learning. One technique I have found useful to supplement the materials provided for the course, is to first look up terms in the Wikipedia and the search for materials in Google Scholar. Wikipedia generally provides a brief, easy to understand overview of the topic and Google Scholar provides authoritative papers (it is not a good idea to cite Wikipedia in your assignment).

As an example the Wikipedia entry for Assessment_for_Learning is very readable and the Google Scholar Entries are useful.

One way Google Scholar could be improved would be with an "Article Available" option. It is frustrating to have numerous articles listed, but then find most are behind pay-walls, so that it is not possible to read more than the abstract, without paying a fee or signing up to a service. I Suggest adding an extra option "Article Available" to allow only those articles where the text is available on-line without the need for payment or signing in.

It would also be useful to have the same open access options (for looking for articles with Creative Commons and similar licenses), as in the non-scholar advanced search, would also be useful.

While institutions, such as USQ, provide access to on-line papers via their library, it is much easier for the staff and the students, if freely available articles are selected for readings. This way the student does not need to login to the university library system to get to the article.

ps: Surprisingly on the topic of e-learning, many of the papers found are from Australian authors. This may be because the Google search engine, seeing I am in Australia is giving me local results, or that doing an Australian course I am searching on topics of particular interest to Australians. But it may be just that Australia is a leader in e-learning.

Saturday, August 20, 2011

Learning On-line Tertiary Teaching for Research-Led Education

In "Postgraduate Certificates in Tertiary Teaching" I looked at some of the courses of study for those wanting to learn about how to teach at university. After looking at the options, I decided to enroll in the Australian National University (ANU) program, as that is where I am an Adjunct Lecturer. However, I decided to do two of the four required units at the University of Southern Queensland, using provision for cross institutional study. This is possible as USQ offers their program on-line. Given that I wanted to learn about how to teach on-line, doing on-line courses from a institution which specialized this is area seemed to make sense.

Units Selected

The courses selected at USQ, in consultation with my education adviser, were:
  1. Assessment, Evaluation and Learning EDU5713, Semester 3, 2011
  2. Online Pedagogy in Practice EDU8114, Semester 1, 2012
These will then be followed by a course at ANU in "Research Supervision" followed by the capstone course.

The intention is to try to develop a form of e-learning which suits a research oriented approach to teaching. While it is easy to say that research should make for better courses, it is difficult to do in practice. World class researchers do not necessarly make world class teachers, nor do they want to take time out from research to give lectures.

But it should be possible to use e-learning techniques to supervise research work by students and also to run better courses, at least at the postgraduate level. These courses may use the same tools, such as Moodle, as undergraduate and vocational courses, but will need to be more flexible, to take into account the fluid nature of research.

Online Research Lead Education for Social Inclusion

Such an on-line approach to research informed teaching might address the problem ANU had with the "2012 Good Universities Guide". The Canberra Times reported ANU did not rate well in some teaching measures ("ANU's teaching score confusing, chief says", BREANNA TUCKER, 18 Aug, 2011 04:00 AM). The university needs to improve teaching quality, without compromising the excellence of its research. One way to do this, would be to provide the staff with on-line tools and training to use them, in a way specifically tailored to researchers.

Early career academics should receive training in how to collaborate on-line as part of their basic education. They would be encouraged to use these skills both for research collaboration and for tutoring students. Staff would then not spend so much time on administrative parts of teaching, not feel the teaching is taking them away from their research and the students would benefit form a more personal, more relevant education.

Some of this is already done in the ANU course "Green Information Technology Strategies" (COMP7310), which uses on-line mentored and collaborative techniques developed by the ACS. These techniques would also help with social inclusion issues, such as gender balance, entry flexibility and the proportion of TAFE accredited students and provide a way to implement the "research-led environment" promoted by the Vice Chancellor, Professor Ian Young.

Enrollment On-line Not Too Daunting

One very useful aspect of enrolling in a course is that it gives a teacher an insight into the difficulty of being a student. Cross-institutional enrollment is just about the hardest thing to do, as it involves coping with the administrative procedures of two different intuitions. At one point it appeared to me it was not possible to do, as the procedure for each institution seemed to say that I had to enroll at the other one first (a situation know in the computer discipline as "deadly embrace"). However, as I was at ANU I enrolled there and then applied to USQ for cross-institutional courses.

The procedure at USQ proved remarkably easy. The information about courses and requirements is complex, but the web site is reasonably well laid out. I sent a message to the inquiry service and received a prompt and helpful reply. What was a little disconcerting at first was that as part of making an inquiry I ended up with an account on the USQ system. This seemed a little intrusive, as I was just making an inquiry, not signing up for a course. But this turned out to be very useful, as when I asked another question, the person answering it had a record of what I had asked before. This way I did not need to repeat everything. What was even more remarkable, was that when I phoned the inquiry line with a quick question, the person answering had my details on screen and could give a very fast answer.

The enrollment process was still not completely clear. There was a four page form to fill in, with a lot of detail. But I found I could bypass all this as a "professional development" student. With this option I simply indicate what unit I want to do and pay the fees myself. As this is not part of a program of study, and I am not asking someone else to pay for it, much of the paperwork is not needed. I simply filled out a half page form and submitted it.

The next day I received an offer by email and accepted it on-line. I got a paper copy of the offer as well but this was not really needed. The only other piece of paper in the process was a one page letter with my student ID and initial password. I assume this is sent on paper for security reasons. What also was a surprise is that so far I have not been asked for any money. The course does not start until November (being in third semester). I assume I will get a bill shortly before then.

Tuesday, April 13, 2010

Workshops on technology-enhanced learning

The last of the USQ/ANU workshops on on technology-enhanced learning is just ending. My blog postings about some of the these are:

The notes from my presentation yesterday is also avialable: "Mentored and collaborative techniques in e-teaching".

ps: I would welcome collaboration on e-learning. My ANU e-learning course details are at: COMP7310 "Green Technology Strategies".

Moodle for electronic assignments

Ron Sharma from USQ is at ANU talking on "Using Moodle, electronic assignment and other tools to support Engineering students" (after a general workshop yesterday). USQ changed from Web CT to the Moodle Learning Management System several years ago. ANU is still making that transition. One difference is that USQ has a central set of standards, whereas this is devolved at ANU to the colleges (Oxbridge style). At USW assignments are electronically set, submitted, marked and returned to the students. This is necessary as the external student numbers are increasing rapidly. It is therefore infeasible to have students submit assignments on paper. Also USQ has to respond to the needs of industry, such as the energy sector, for engineering education.

At USQ the same Moodle template is used for all courses at the university, with the same standard information resources, such as contacts for the course and assessment. This is provided at the top of the main screen for each Moodle course. The specific course content then follows below. This looks to me a very good approach, so that students knew where to find the information for each course . Having standard conditions for assignment submission saves confusion.

Professor Sharma reported that using the LMS resulted in a reduction in lecture and tutorial attendance from 70% to 30%. This seems in line with my experience. He suggested that just putting lecture notes and audio recordings online was not sufficient: it was necessary to also provide online tutorial materials. This makes sense to me and I was assuming that about 25% of the students would still want to attend in person. The issue then is from a business point of view is if the university can afford to support those students. My suggestion for ANU was to replace the large lecture theaters (which typically easiest 100 or more), with small ones which seat about 24 students. This would be sufficient students to have a class and provide an audience for the lecturer to perform to for audio and video recording.

Professor Sharma teaching energy auditing to the engineering students. This is similar to he green ICT energy audit I teach in Green Technology Strategies.

Providing a laboratory for students at home

Alfio Parisi from University of Southern Queensland is talk on "Remote laboratories and experiments, experimental kits supporting first year DE students" at ANU in Canberra. USQ provide Experiment kits, portable lecture demonstrations, remote viewing astronomical observatory.

Experiment Kits fit in a standard size box for posting and costs less than $40. First year students buy the kit through the bookstore and it is posted to anywhere in the world. There are now about ten experiments available. An example is to measure the spring constant of a spring. The kits have been checked for safety. See:Take-home physics experiment kit for on-campus and off-campus students (J Turner, 2008).

Instruments on to top of the university building measures solar UV in real time. This is then used by the students. Web based display show reading from the instruments for the students. One limitation is that the instruments are not effective after dark.

Portable Lecture Demonstrations consist of short video clips of physics demonstrations. These are similar to the demonstrations typically used in the classroom, but provided online for remote students and those who cannot attend classes.

The remote viewing astronomical observatory is located near Toowomba and has a remote controlled telescope, weather station and fast Internet connection. The project is with the University of Louisville, who can use the telescope during the day. In return USQ can use the Moore Observatory in the USA during the Australian day. A new telescope is planned to expand the facilities.

Online laboratories for students

Alfio Parisi from University of Southern Queensland will talk on "Remote laboratories and experiments, experimental kits supporting first year DE students" at ANU in Canberra, 11am. This will be followed by Ron Sharma on "Using Moodle, electronic assignment and other tools to support Engineering students" at 11:30am. Staff from USQ are at ANU in Canberra to talk about technology assisted learning. Yesterday there was a general workshop and today there are some specific discipline talks.

Monday, April 12, 2010

Improving academics use of technology

The last presentation for the day at the workshop on technology-enhanced learning at ANU was by Romina Jamieson-Proctor (USQ) on "Learning to Design, Designing to Learn: improving academics' use of technology to enhance learning". She discussed how to motivate staff to use new techniques. This included providing examples of good practice and some competitions.

Romina's tips were good, but perhaps we need to treat e-learning as a core skill for educators. We then can prepare formal courses for educators to learn how to do online education. In response to a question along these lines Romina pointed out that new teachers in Queensland require an ICT Certificate.

Online communities for post-graduate education

The speaker after my Green ICT presentation at the second workshop on technology-enhanced learning at ANU was Peter Evans (USQ) on "Using e-Learning technologies and online communities to support post-graduate education". He argued that educators have to be open to using the technology which their students already use, such as instant messaging and social networking.

USQ requires all courses to have an online component, with at least a description of the course, but Peter argued that so much more could be done. He questioned why courses were divided into 13 week blocks and suggested that e-portfolios could be used to pull the material together. I did not find this a convincing argument. If he course designers and educators have not built the courses into a coherent whole, it seems difficult to see why, or how, the students would do this.

What I found most useful was Peter's suggestion to use the students to influence the behaviour of other educators. He suggested that by showing the students how to use online techniques the students will then ask for these facilities in courses. Rather than confront staff, the learning techniques can be introduced as a technical option of the system tools.

Peter also mentioned is knowledgeGarden web site where he provides some materials for advanced learning technologies and learning communities.